Friday, April 29, 2005

Foolproof Death Penalty?

The governor of Massachusetts has introduced a bill that would reinstate the death penalty in that state. According to the governor, the bill would ensure a virtually foolproof death penalty. His assessment of his bill:
"To the extent that is humanly possible," Mr. Romney said at a news conference, "this would not ever result in a questionable execution."
Of course, the big problem is the "humanly possible" part. Human possibility is no small limitation. There is no way to create a death penalty scheme that could ensure that no innocent person was executed. Don't get me wrong. I would trade Texas's death penalty scheme for what Gov. Romney has proposed any day. But foolproof? That's simply not possible, and Gov. Romney knows it.

1 Comments:

Anonymous Gideon said...

Here's another problem:

"Defendants who had previously been convicted of first-degree murder or were serving life sentences without parole would also be eligible."

Umm, ex-post facto?

I do like the provisions regarding limited crimes and two or maybe three attorneys representing capital defendants and the two juries bit - that's interesting.

4/30/2005 8:02 AM  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home